Article 2 and Popular Sovereignty: San Marino Between Representation and Direct Democracy

This article explores the concept of sovereignty in San Marino, emphasizing the balance between representative democracy and direct citizen participation.

· 2 min read

by Tommy Fantini

After analyzing the international opening of Article 1, the heart of the Declaration of Rights of Citizens and the fundamental principles of the San Marino legal system shifts to another equally central principle: sovereignty.

Article 2 is clear, direct, almost essential in its formulation:

“The sovereignty of the Republic resides in the people, who exercise it in the statutory forms of representative democracy. The law will regulate the Arengo and other institutions of direct democracy.”

In these few lines, the balance that defines the San Marino political system is concentrated: on one side representation, on the other the direct participation of citizens.

Sovereignty: Not an Abstract Concept

To assert that sovereignty resides in the people is not a symbolic formula. In San Marino, this principle finds a concrete, historically rooted expression.

The people are not only the theoretical source of power but are also, at least in part, direct exercisers of it. However, as in most modern democracies, the ordinary exercise of sovereignty occurs through representative democracy, that is, through the Grand and General Council elected by the citizens.

But it is precisely in the second part of the article that the specificity of San Marino emerges.

The Arengo: A Tradition Becomes an Institution

The reference to the Arengo is not accidental. It is an ancient institution, rooted in the medieval history of the Republic, when heads of families gathered to make collective decisions.

Today, the Arengo is no longer a physical assembly but has transformed into a modern tool: the Istanze d’Arengo.

Twice a year, on the occasion of the installation of the Captains Regent (April and October), every citizen can submit a request on topics of public interest. These requests are then discussed by the Grand and General Council.

They are not automatically binding but represent a direct channel between citizens and institutions, with significant political value.

Referendums: Direct Decision-Making Power

Alongside the Arengo, San Marino provides for other instruments of direct democracy, among which the most relevant is the referendum.

There are different types:

  • Proposed Referendum: allows citizens to propose new laws or legislative amendments
  • Abrogative Referendum: allows for the repeal of existing laws
  • Confirmative Referendum (in certain circumstances): to validate or reject specific decisions

These tools give citizens real power to influence the legal framework, going beyond mere delegation to elected representatives.

A Delicate Yet Functional Balance

Article 2 thus outlines a balanced system. The daily management of the State is entrusted to representative bodies, but the people retain tools to intervene directly.

It is a form of mixed democracy, combining institutional stability and popular participation.

And this is not a secondary detail: in a small State like San Marino, this balance allows for a more direct relationship between citizens and politics, making the system potentially more responsive and attuned to the real needs of the population.

A Modernity Born from History

What is striking is how seemingly modern tools, such as referendums or popular requests, are actually the evolution of ancient practices.

San Marino once again demonstrates a distinctive characteristic: innovating without breaking with its own tradition.

Article 2 is not just a norm on sovereignty but a declaration of identity: power belongs to the people, and the system is built to never forget that.

Share
The author of this editorial

The il Pianello newsroom covers news and in-depth reporting from the Republic of San Marino and Romagna.

All articles →

Found a mistake or have a tip? Write to the newsroom.

Read also

Search Il Pianello